PG&E wants customers to pay $3.6 billion more a year for wildfire safety

EWG: Shareholders, not ratepayers, should shoulder costs of upgrading utility’s hazardous grid

SAN FRANCISCO – Pacific Gas and Electric, or PG&E, on Wednesday asked state regulators to approve a $3.6 billion rate hike on its roughly 16 million customers to fund measures aimed at reducing deadly wildfires like those caused by its unmaintained transmission lines. The change would leave ratepayers with an unfair $436 average annual increase in their energy bills.

PG&E has told the California Public Utilities Commission, or CPUC, that the rate hike would pay the cost of burying more power lines, removing dead, dying and diseased trees that could fall onto above-ground transmission lines, and expanding gas pipelines. But PG&E should pay these costs – and drop its ongoing efforts to make it harder for solar power to join the grid as a vital resource for fighting the climate crisis.

The Environmental Working Group said the outrageous request points up the unfairness of the state-sanctioned monopoly utility model, which pushes costs onto customers, not PG&E’s investor-owners.

“The enormous rate hike PG&E has requested will most hurt middle- and low-income families, many of whom are already struggling to stay afloat,” said Environmental Working Group President and Bay Area resident Ken Cook. “The utility and its shareholders should shoulder the costs of these safety measures, considering it was the company’s own reckless negligence that was responsible for the recent deadly fires that killed scores of people and damaged and destroyed property.”

The 2018 Camp Fire, caused by unmaintained PG&E transmission lines, killed scores of people and destroyed the town of Paradise. The company ultimately pled guilty to 84 counts of manslaughter for the deaths of those who died because of the fire.

PG&E is joining forces with two other investor-owned utilities, Southern California Edison and San Diego Power & Light, to push the CPUC to quash the state’s popular rooftop solar program, often referred to as Net Energy Metering, or NEM.

NEM has benefited millions of homeowners and businesses across the state by paying them for excess energy their solar panels send back to the grid. The scheme by the big three utilities under consideration by the CPUC would largely end net metering and let them pocket much of the money, rather than sending it to ratepayers.

Crushing rooftop solar has implications for future wildfires

The only concrete way to prevent future wildfires caused by these large utilities is to reform the current model of centralized electricity distribution that sends energy hundreds of miles through the dry, drought-ridden central and Northern California landscape covered in brush that fuels these fires.

Locally generated and distributed renewable electricity, primarily from solar, would dramatically reduce rolling blackouts initiated by utilities to prevent fires that are often triggered by power lines traversing the state.

In 2018, the California Independent System Operator, which coordinates access to transmission lines and manages a range of energy resources, canceled 18 transmission projects and 21 revisions of other projects, avoiding $2.6 billion in future costs. It cited customer investments in solar and energy efficiency as the reason.

EWG is a party to the PUC’s proceeding on the utility’s scheme to gut rooftop solar. In testimony submitted on June 18 to the CPUC in the rooftop solar fight, Cook urged the commission to seriously consider scrapping the current monopoly business model that will only increase the threat of wildfires, as well as delay utilities’ commitment to lowering carbon emissions to combat the climate crisis.


The Environmental Working Group is a nonprofit, non-partisan organization that empowers people to live healthier lives in a healthier environment. Through research, advocacy and unique education tools, EWG drives consumer choice and civic action. Visit for more information.

Guide to Solar Energy

We’ve partnered with one of the most trusted solar industry experts, EnergySage, to offer independent educational resources and the ability to explore your solar options from the comfort of your home.

Disqus Comments

Related News

Continue Reading