Sign up to receive email updates, action alerts & health tips from EWG. [Privacy]

Environmental Triggers & New Clues

Overloaded?: Environmental Triggers & New Clues

December 13, 2004

Part 1:

Environmental triggers are a neglected component of autism research

There is no doubt that an environmental factor has contributed to the dramatic increase in the incidence of autism over the past 15 years. Genetic factors are a component in the condition-concurrent rates of autism in identical twins approach 90 percent-but rates of inherited genetic diseases do not change abruptly in one generation, whereas autism rates skyrocketed during the 1990s. Rates of autism in the United States increased from fewer than 6 cases per 10,000 children in the 1980s to more than 60 per 10,000 children today (Blaxill 2004a). The American Academy of Pediatrics and the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) currently estimate that autism affects one in every 166 children (AAP 2004). Improved diagnosis does not adequately account for this increase (Blaxill 2004a, Croen 2003).

Autism is a complex neurological disorder characterized by severely impaired social interaction and language skills. The social and economic costs of the autism epidemic are staggering. In 2003, the Autism Society of America estimated the cost of treating the 1.5 million cases of autism to be $90 billion per year rising to $200-400 billion by 2010 (ASA 2003). In addition to the economic costs of treatment, autism is a tremendous burden to family members who must provide lifelong care to loved ones affected by the disorder.

There has been little progress in identifying pre- and post-natal environmental exposures that might trigger the severe impacts to brain development, intestinal and immune dysregulation that characterize autism disorders (London 2000). Hundreds of studies have explored the genetic roots of the autism epidemic, but none has uncovered a single gene or vulnerability to account for more than a fraction of cases.

Children's exposure to mercury in immunizations has been a long-standing concern of autism advocates-and for good reason. Mercury is highly toxic to brain cells and other body systems impacted by autism. Several classic features of autism-speech loss and loss of social and communication skills-are signature traits of mercury poisoning. Many parents report children slipping into autism shortly after receiving multiple mercury-containing vaccinations.

One in every six children born in the United States, or 630,000 per year, are exposed to potentially unsafe levels of mercury during pregnancy from contaminated seafood in the maternal diet, creating a background level of exposure that could be exacerbated by cumulative and frequent mercury doses from vaccinations (Mahaffey 2004). Virtually all children in the U.S. were vaccinated repeatedly with mercury-containing vaccine during the 1990s; if a percentage of these children had a metabolic imbalance that increased their vulnerability to mercury, this near universal exposure could help explain the dramatic nationwide increase in autism that followed directly on the heels of this abrupt rise in thimerosal use. The findings discussed here, that autistic children share a common deficit in antioxidant protection, call into question the conclusion that mercury in vaccines is uniformly safe for all children, and underscores the need for a broader look at the role of environmental chemicals in the autism epidemic.

Every existing study that has failed to find a link between thimerosal exposure and autism has looked at disease rates in vaccinated children without regard to their individual metabolism. To properly investigate the role of mercury-containing shots in a vulnerable group, researchers would have to compare autism rates in children with the same type of vulnerability. This has not been done.

Important New Finding offers clues to autism prevention and treatment

In an exciting breakthrough, Dr. Jill James of the University of Arkansas School of Medicine has documented a unique metabolic profile in 95 autistic children with regressive autism. (James 2004a, 2004b) Regressive autism is a form of the disease in which children develop normally for a certain period before losing previously acquired language or behaviors and being diagnosed with autism.

The metabolic profile in the James study children manifests as a severe imbalance in the ratio of active to inactive glutathione in autistic children, compared to a group of healthy control children (James 2004a, 2004b). Glutathione, a potent antioxidant, is the body's most important tool for detoxifying and excreting metals.

Table. Autistic children have significant differences in every measure of antioxidant capacity and oxidative stress

Metabolite Number of Healthy Controls Average in Autistic Children Average in Healthy Children Difference in autistic group p-value
Homocysteine (umol/L) 75 5.5 5.9 7% less 0.05
Cysteine (umol/L) 75 161 205 22% less <0.0001
Active Glutathione:
    Total:tGSH
    (umol/L)
75 5.1 7.5 31% less <0.0001
    Free:
    fGSH (umol/L)
49 1.5 2.1 30% less <0.0001
Inactive Glutathione: GSSG (nmol/L) 49 0.41 0.31 34% more 0.0015
Glutathione ratio (unitless)
    tGSH/GSSG 49 16.7 27.6 40% less <0.0001
    fGSH/GSSG 49 5.0 7.1 30% less <0.0001

 

Source: James 2004b

The James study shows that children with regressive autism have consistently elevated levels of oxidative stress as compared to normal healthy children. Individuals with reduced glutathione antioxidant capacity will be under chronic oxidative stress and will be more vulnerable to toxic compounds that act primarily through oxidative damage, including mercury (James 2004). Oxidative stress plays a key role in several important degenerative diseases of the brain and nervous system, including Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, Huntington's disease, and schizophrenia (Shulz 2000, Granot 2004).

graphic: glutathione, the body's most important defense against toxic chemicals, is overwhelmed in autistic children

Dr. James' findings shift the focus of research from single genes to a broader metabolic disorder shared by the vast majority of autistic children. They also indicate a mechanism by which autistic children would be more sensitive to chemicals that cause oxidative stress and damage their developing brain and nervous system. In another recent study Dr. James found that glutathione protects brain cells from oxidative damage and cell death caused by thimerosal exposure (James 2005). Numerous studies have confirmed the toxicity of metals to brain cells at doses similar to those experienced by vaccinated children (Makani 2002, Shanker 2003, Baskin 2003, Waly 2004, Ueha-Ishibashi 2004).

These findings raise serious concerns about the studies that have allegedly proven the safety of mercury in vaccines. While Dr. James' results do not prove that mercury in vaccinations causes autism or other neurodevelopmental disorders, they significantly strengthen that possibility by identifying a metabolic imbalance common to nearly all autistic children that would make these children poorly equipped to mount a defense against the large doses of mercury they all received via vaccines.