Lead Pollution at Outdoor Firing Ranges: Poisonous Pastime
“We fired round after round, match after match, without realizing what lead could do to us.”
—Joseph P. Tartaro, Second Amendment Foundation news release, January 10, 1998
Choked by stagnant markets and growing social disapproval, the gun industry has made increasing the number of shooting ranges the keystone of its survival strategy. Introducing kids to guns is a key element of the industry plan.
But lead doesn’t mix with children and the environment. Lead is one of the most deadly toxins on the planet. Poisonous Pastime documents in detail the ways in which the shooting range industry is poisoning children and heavily polluting the environment with lead and other toxins:
- Most ammunition used at ranges is made of lead....between 400 and 600 tons of lead are used each day to make bullets and “a high proportion of it is left to clutter up shooting ranges.” It is no wonder,then, that numerous studies—since at least the 1970s—have documented that outdoor shooting ranges are major sources of lead pollution in the environment, and that indoor shooting ranges are significant sources of lead poisoning among people who use them.
Poisoning Kids
Tragically, children—the gun industry’s prime target—are most vulnerable to the toxic effects of lead:
- Lead is particularly harmful to the rapidly developing brains and nervous systems of fetuses and young children. This harm has been well-studied in actual human cases, not mere theoretical calculations, animal studies, or academic conjecture....Their protection hinges on vigilant parents and aggressive public health authorities....“It makes you stupid,” in the words of one lead testing expert, and the damage is irreversible.
Parents often put their own children at risk, because they do not know that their visits to the local range can result in lead poisoning of the kids at home:
- Because lead dust settles on clothing, shoes, and accessories worn or used at the range, the families of persons who work at or use firing ranges are also subject to “take-home” exposure to lead dust. This can cause secondary lead poisoning, particularly in children....shooters can even contaminate their children’s clothing by washing them together with the clothes they wore to the range.
National Rifle Association publications and other gun magazines aimed at children often encourage them to “get into” reloading their own ammunition, a process which sometimes includes the dangerous process of casting lead bullets:
- Melting lead produces a fume which can remain airborne for several hours, is easily inhaled, and can contaminate surfaces. The director of a New Hampshire occupational health center said some of the worst cases of lead poisoning he has seen have been in people who make their own bullets....“That’s a wonderful way to poison not only yourself but members of your family,” said another state health official.
Poisonous Pastime also documents the risk shooting ranges pose to other third parties, like range employees, construction workers on range facilities, and those who share buildings with ranges, live, or work near ranges:
- A day-care center in Clearwater, Florida, was forced to close and the children were required to have blood tests after it was discovered that a neighboring indoor shooting range was venting lead-contaminated air into the center’s playground area....California health officials have seen “some serious lead poisoning cases among construction employees engaged in demolition of a firing range, as well as among these employees’ children.”
Wrecking the Environment
Besides poisoning kids and others, shooting ranges are wrecking the environment at a prodigious pace:
- According to Sports Afield, “the quantity of recreational lead deposited in the environment is enormous. For example, at some trap and skeet ranges, lead shot densities of 1.5 billion pellets per acre have been recorded. That’s 334 pellets in every square foot.” This massive pollution at shooting ranges is entirely separate from another question, posed by a U.S. Forest Service official at a gun industry shooting range symposium, of “where the lead is going for the millions of shooters who currently are not using established ranges,” but are instead shooting on open public land.
This frightful record happens because the shooting range business operates “under the radar.” These problems are no secret within the industry itself: Poisonous Pastime is based largely on records of internal industry meetings and gun industry publications. Although some newer shooting ranges incorporate state-of-the-art environmental and public-health controls, thousands of ranges all over America are operated on shoe-string budgets. Many are operated as informally as sandlot baseball diamonds, without even the most elementary protection for their users, the environment, and the public:
- The Boston-based Strategic Planning Institute found in a recent report outlining a gun industry survival strategy for the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) that “a large majority of shooting facilities in the country are not professionally managed, commercial operations.”
Similarly, a major supplier of shooting range equipment, Caswell International Corp., was reported in 1989 by the NRA’s American Rifleman magazine to have found that “a lot of people trying to get in on a shoestring” in the shooting range market were “cutting corners on costs that resulted in substandard ranges in terms of safety, environmental concerns and cleanliness.” An engineering consulting firm specializing in shooting ranges notes in its promotional materials that the increased attention to lead contamination and human health exposure “has put range owners and operators into areas outside of their expertise.”
The industry chooses to downplay the seriousness of its problems, hide them from the general public, and allow thousands of unregulated shooting sites to continue to operate without strict oversight.
What Can be Done? Poisonous Pastime lists specific things that can be done by the vast majority of Americans who do not own guns and have no interest in allowing the shooting range industry’s reckless rampage to continue. Here are a few examples from among many others that activists can pursue to protect kids and the environment:
- All children who have any direct or indirect exposure to a hooting range or to reloading should immediately have their blood lead levels tested.
- No children should be allowed at shooting ranges, nor should they participate in or be exposed to ammunition reloading, since there is no “safe” level of lead exposure for children.
- Local activists can form coalitions with health and environmental groups to conduct “audits” of shooting ranges to check lead levels at ranges and ensure compliance with all applicable laws and regulations, including zoning, noise, environment, as well as health and safety.
- Congress can give first priority for tax funds that are now used to promote shooting ranges to cleaning up and repairing lead damage to public lands caused by the so-called “shooting sports.”
- Congress should forbid use of federal dollars for any range that permits use of assault weapons, high-capacity magazines, or machine guns.
- The lead hazard at shooting ranges calls into question the wisdom of encouraging or requiring firearm safety training as a mechanism to reduce firearm-related violence, and demonstrates the folly of supporting range development with public funds.
The Violence Policy Center is a national educational organization working to stop gun death and injury in America through research, analysis, and advocacy for effective firearms policy. For more information and a full copy of the May 2001 study, Poisonous Pastime: The Health Risks of Target Ranges and Lead to Children, Families, and the Environment, please contact Naomi Seligman at 202-822-8200 ext. 105 or nseligman@vpc.org.
News Release
WASHINGTON, DC - The Violence Policy Center (VPC) and the Environmental Working Group (EWG) today released Poisonous Pastime: The Health Risks of Shooting Ranges and Lead to Children, Families, and the Environment. The 71-page study documents how shooting ranges are poisoning children and polluting the environment with lead, yet remain almost entirely unregulated-exempt from even the Bush Administration's new lead pollution reporting rules.
Poisonous Pastime documents how parents often put their own children at risk because they do not know that their visits to the local shooting range can result in lead poisoning of their children at home. Lead poisoning is known to cause terribly debilitating and sometimes fatal effects on children and adults.
"There is no question that the toxic levels of lead at shooting ranges are endangering America's children and families," VPC Senior Policy Analyst and report author Tom Diaz said today. "No amount of lead exposure is known to be completely safe for a child. Poisonous Pastime reveals for the first time that the gun industry-through toxic and unregulated ranges-is sacrificing the health of our children for profit."
Poisonous Pastime details how outdoor firing ranges put more lead into the environment than nearly any other major industrial sector in the U.S., yet they remain almost entirely unregulated. In just two years a typical outdoor firing range can have lead contamination equivalent to a five-acre Superfund site.
The study reveals how school administrators throughout the country were oblivious to the dangers of lead - from school shooting ranges - until students were found to have elevated blood levels.
"Every one of the 1,800 firing ranges in the U.S. represents a piece of land so highly contaminated with lead that it would require a massive clean-up effort to be safe for wildlife or any industrial or residential use," said EWG Research Director Jane Houlihan.
Poisonous Pastime finds that the shooting range industry downplays the seriousness of its problems, hides them from the general public, and allows thousands of unregulated shooting sites to continue to operate without strict oversight. It is based largely on the records of internal industry meetings and gun industry publications. The report includes recommendations at both local and federal levels.
California News Release
OAKLAND, Calif. -- Guns can be hazardous to your health even if you don't get shot with one, according to a new study of the harm to people and the environment from lead pollution at shooting ranges in California and nationwide.
"Poisonous Pastime" by the Violence Policy Center and Environmental Working Group documents how shooting ranges are poisoning children and polluting the environment with lead, yet remain almost entirely unregulated - exempt even from the Bush Administration's new lead pollution reporting rules. Despite the environmental threat and the health costs, cities, counties, school districts, state universities and parks districts throughout California maintain shooting ranges, at least in part with tax dollars.
The report, available Tuesday at www.ewg.org or www.vpc.org, warns that parents who don't know they're bringing home lead from the shooting range are putting their own children at risk for lead poisoning, which can cause severe learning disabilities and other serious health problems. There also is a growing body of evidence that lead poisoning may be a contributing cause of violent criminal behavior in some people.
"There is no question that the toxic levels of lead at shooting ranges are endangering America's children and families," said Tom Diaz of VPC, principal author of the report.
The study found that outdoor firing ranges put more lead into the environment than almost any other major industrial sector in the U.S. According to EWG and VPC, in just three years a typical firing range can become as contaminated with lead as a five-acre Superfund site, and the amount of waste lead contained in a single .45-caliber bullet is enough to contaminate the daily drinking water supply of a city the size of San Francisco to a level deemed unsafe by the U.S. EPA.
"It's very likely that every one of the 3,200 outdoor firing ranges in the U.S. is so highly contaminated with lead that a massive cleanup effort would be required to make it safe for any other industrial or residential use," said EWG Research Director Jane Houlihan.
Indoor ranges expose workers and shooters to extremely high levels of airborne lead dust they may unwittingly take home to their families. According to the California Department of Health Services, some shooting range employees have been found to have blood lead levels more than 7.5 times higher than the lead poisoning threshold of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control.
Yet shooting ranges remain largely outside both federal and state regulation. No state license is required to operate a shooting range, nor does the state even know how many shooting ranges there are in California or their locations. The National Rifle Association and its affiliated National Shooting Sports Foundation list more than 200 places to shoot in California. (The NRA's list of California shooting ranges by city is at www.nrahq.com/shooting/shootingrange/findlocal.asp)
In California, EWG and VPC also found:
- State law specifically exempts shooting ranges from civil liability or criminal prosecution for noise pollution.
- The state Department of Toxic Substances Control, like the U.S. EPA, has authority over shooting ranges only if they are abandoned and classified as toxic dump sites.
- State labor law requires blood tests for all workers at risk of lead poisoning, but very few ranges provide testing for their employees, let alone customers.
"Shooting ranges are like toxic waste dumps," said Bill Walker, California director of EWG. "They present themselves as good neighbors, but their very existence in the community is a threat to the environment and public health. We've got to start holding the gun industry accountable for lead poisoning and lead pollution as well as gun violence."